When Politics Become Too Divisive
January 8th, 2011Today a terrible tragedy struck when a lunatic attempted to assassinate Rep. Gabrielle Giffords in Arizona and killed several others at her event. This awful episode shows how horribly extreme the political climate has become in the U.S. And I’m not talking about the man who attacked a member of Congress: I’m talking about all of the pundits who are trying to make this senseless act a political issue.
The reality of the situation is that politics had nothing – nothing – to do with what occurred today. You don’t need to analyze this idiot’s political affiliations. When someone decides to do something crazy, his politics are irrelevant: the act was insane. There’s no logic in trying to gun down a member of Congress, even if you don’t like what he or she stands for. Any attempt to do so is not the result of divisive politics or violent rhetoric. It’s a chemical imbalance or some other brain problem that results in a psychotic episode.
What makes it even more absurd that this act could have been merely political is who was targeted. Rep Giffords is a moderate by any definition. This wasn’t Nancy Pelosi or Barney Frank. She is a Blue Dog Democrat, which means she’s relatively conservative in her fiscal views. She opposed the DC gun ban. She supports strong immigration measures. But she also isn’t particularly conservative. She is pro-choice. She voted for the Obama stimulus in 2009. Unless this gunman has a particular aversion to moderates, then it couldn’t have been political. This further shows that he isn’t a fringe political wacko — he’s just a wacko.
From today for the next few weeks or months, people on TV will debate this guy’s political motivation. They’ll criticize violent political rhetoric. But they’re wasting their time. None of that actually mattered here. This person developed a psychotic obsession that he exercised through violence. This isn’t that different from your usual serial killer in that they are both mentally deranged.
So as the talking heads on TV drone on about how this episode might have been prevented, they’ll develop lots of grand theories and assertions of how to make things better. But they’ll all be empty and worthless. The sad truth is that this couldn’t been prevented by more enlightened political discourse, because there will always be psychotic people with the will and means to commit violent acts. This isn’t a result of violent rhetoric or political extremism; it’s a result of psychoses.
There have been lunatics killing people since the beginning of time, and there’s no way to ensure that they won’t in the future. While some psychologist, friend, or relative might have discovered this man’s problems earlier to prevent the problem, no political pundit or new commentator could have helped.