Eternal Badness
Friday, November 12th, 2004Now that the election is finally over, I intend to get back to writing on a variety of various topics, rather than focusing almost entirely on political issues. Of course, I will not be able to avoid the occasional political-oriented rant from time to time, but those will be more sporadic than before. Tonight I wish to write on a topic inspired by a movie I recently saw.
When traveling on a plane from New York to California, one is in for a very long ride. Luckily, most airlines show a movie or two along the way to help the time go a little bit faster. If the movie isn’t one that looks completely terrible or that I have already seen (and don’t wish to see again), I usually watch it. After all, watching a movie certainly helps to pass the time. A few weeks ago, one of these movies was the romantic comedy, “13 going on 30”.
This film starred Jennifer Garner as a 30-something woman who was 13 until one day when she made a wish that she was 30. So suddenly, she’s 30; she missed out on about 20 years of her life; and she has a job at a magazine that seems a lot like “People”. The movie basically served as a female version of the early Tom Hanks film, “Big”. Big, however, seemed a little bit better, but “13 Going on 30” wasn’t completely terrible – it had its moments. But I do not mention this film in order to critique it.
Instead, I want to address a theme that this, and many other films, often have in common: the bad person becoming nice. You know the story. The movie starts and the audience sees Joe acting like a complete jerk. Then, something happens in the story. Suddenly, Joe has a revelation and decides to abandon his jerky ways and become a really sweet guy. Sometimes the jerk is the main character, and other times the main character helps to reform a jerk. This is especially common in the films where the good girl successfully tames the “bad boy”.
So what’s my beef with the jerk-becoming-nice theme? It’s just so unrealistic. Don’t get me wrong. It would be really nice if this kind of stuff happened in real life, it just never does. Let me explain a bit.
Think, if you will, about a jerk that you know. Now, try to imagine that person as a really sweet person. It doesn’t work, right? That’s because being a jerk is this person’s very essence. If this person wasn’t a jerk, s/he would not know what to do with himself/herself. Being a jerk isn’t a choice; it’s a way of life.
But perhaps you remain unconvinced. Okay, let’s try something else: think about back when you were in high school or college. Now think about two or three of the biggest jerks you can remember. If you have seen any of these people subsequently (a number of years later), have they changed? I’d be willing to bet that they haven’t.
So what causes this? Why do jerks stay jerks? I think the major reason this occur stems from the fact that they know that they bask in their jerkness. I think it’s exceedingly rare that someone is truly hateful or obnoxious and doesn’t realize that people would view them in this way. They like being jerks. The media and entertainment industry has made it abundantly clear what type of person is considered nice. Unless this jerk lives under a rock, s/he should have a pretty good idea of what behavior would necessitate his/her seeming to be nice or pleasant. Thus, it should come as no surprise that s/he does not act in this way.
One last example. How about some non-jerk characteristics. What are some behaviors that nice or pleasant people exhibit? Nice people hold the doors for others; nice people offer to trade their seat with a woman who wants to sit with her children on a plane; nice people don’t litter. So if someone never holds the door for others, fails to trade seats with a woman wanting to sit with her children, and throws his/her Starbuck’s cups in the street, then s/he should have some clue that s/he is a jerk.
Since jerks tend to know that they are jerks, they would actually have to truly want to change the way they are to become a nice person. While the sudden revelation in films causes this change, in real life such revelations don’t really happen. But even if they did happen, I don’t think that they would lead to the change that they do in the movies. Why? Because changing is hard. If you’re a jerk trying to become nice, you will have to change your entire way of life. Suddenly you are going to have to be courteous in most situations and reevaluate entirely the way you communicate with others. When’s the last time you ever heard someone do such a thing? Probably never. Ya know why? Because jerks don’t change.
And that’s fine. The world needs jerks. Imagine how odd it would be if everyone in the world was nice. It would be like we were stuck in the Disney World ride “It’s a Small World” – it would be torture. If it wasn’t for jerks, we wouldn’t be so happy when we found people who were nice. Jerks, while annoying, make life challenging and interesting. This is why jerk bosses sometimes actually end up causing more professional growth than nice bosses. They might be jerks, but you hate them so much that you don’t want to give them an opportunity to be a jerk when it comes to the work you do, so you go above and beyond what you might otherwise do. Now I’m not saying jerks are great; they’re still generally pieces of crap. All I’m saying is that the world wouldn’t be the same without them.